Re: Fw: Ac. Pratapaditya--viplav to save the Mission

----- Original Message -----
From: ravipratap singh
To: SGoenka ; didianandarama@gmail.com
Cc: acaryasood@yahoo.com ; AnandaMarg@googlegroups.com
Sent: 10 January, 2008 8:30 PM
Subject: Re: Fw: Ac. Pratapaditya--viplav to save the Mission
Dear Brother Ac Shuddhatmananda Avadhutaji/Didi Anandaramaji , Kindly follow the spirit of my letter. Many matters cannot and should not be discussed through e-mail. I feel A. M. philosophy does not support leadership of one man. It is good that wonderful movement is emerging but the problem is how to bring coordinated cooperation between grihies and W.T. workers. It is in that direction that I have pointed one solution for the consideration of you all. We should not, however, challenge amongst ourselves each other's information, capacity or knowledge. Many of us are capable of making impossible possible by His grace, if we are sincere to Him, and unselfish. Some of us have been given special training for leading the society as well as the organization provided they are heard or given opportunity to serve. Try to think and discuss about the right solution. If Hon. P.P. and G.S. were not at fault they should have either protested against the improper orders passed in their names or should have walked out of their offices. The former President late Ac. Raghunath Prasadji recognized the provincial committees and the present wonderful movement originated. Hon. P.P. and G.S. have never been decisive and it appears that collective leadership could never emerge. Purodhas have been made in many cases on partition basis and the lifetime PP does appear workable. By constitution I mean the constitution registered under the societies act, which confirms the Presidential system. Study the earliest news bulletin in which Shrii Shrii Anandmurtijee relinquished the office in favour of Shri P. R. Sarkar. It is a pointer to the system He liked, one the spiritual head and the other the organizational head, earlier in the same body, later in the two persons. Unity is laudable but it is not possible without sacrificing instincts. May be several small units under one central body, then in that case, would be a workable proposition for the time being. Immediate problem is to carry on the work of the Mission which has been utterly neglected so far. Study the import of lectures 10&14 in Namah Shivaya Shantaya and PRAMA. Excuse me if feelings are hurt. I never meant that. With love and respect to you and all in His service.Truly YoursAc. PratapadityaGorakhpur


On Mon, 07 Jan 2008
SGoenka wrote :
>>----- Original Message ----->
From: Ac Shuddhatmananda Avadhuta>
To: sgoenka@gogoindia.com ; acaryasood@yahoo.com ; AnandaMarg@googlegroups.com>Sent: 06 January, 2008 3:40 AM
>Subject: RE: Ac. Pratapaditya--viplav to save the Mission
>>>Dear A'c Pratapadityaji,>Namaskar. Your message for new year is inspiring. But I could not understand the following sentence:
>>"The need now is to reconstruct the organizational structure according to the Constitution keeping the spirit of Caryacarya In short, it should be the presidential system, the President being a non-WT Grihii. This President would be the ideal and not the idol."
>>can you please explain nicely, what do you mean?
>>Before one President was a family person who was working under present PP dadaji. When PP dadaji became inactive, few people took the adventage and utilized that oppertunity and president was utilized to fulfill their wish. According to carya carya, the president post is not an independent post but he facilitates the work of Purodha Pramukh and appointed by also the Purodha pramukh.>>In Constitution there is not mentioned whether the president and the members will be family margiis or Sanyasiis. The central committee members, president and Purodha pramukh can be either Sanyasii or Grhii according to their qualification. But according to carya carya, the Central committee members will be Purodhas only. Constitution is built upon carya carya. So everything is clearly mentioned in Carya carya, not in constitution. If we think present PP dadaji or GS dadaji are puppets in the hands of few selfish people, it is wrong. When PP dada was able to work independently, he was taking mostly discissions with other Purodha board membrs. But he is unable to do that now due to his old age. Others are using his power cunningly. Same is with GS dadaji. This is not the fault of PP or GS dadaji.>> from your letter, I feel again the same thing is going to be repeated, the clash in btween family and sanyasiis. No single person family or sanyasii can run Baba's mission by becoming PP or president, without others support and Baba's grace. Nobody is perfect. So it will be better to find a solution which will be suitable for all and beneficial for the future of Baba's mission.>>With brotherly love and best wishes, in Him>D Shuddhatmananda